Member-only story
The Most Controversial Problem in Philosophy
In the corridors of philosophical study, the “Sleeping Beauty Problem” appears as a particularly challenging puzzle. It brings to light the complications of probability and belief, making us closely examine the effect of information — or its obvious lack — on our guesses about the universe’s unfolding events.
Starting with Sleeping Beauty herself, who agrees to join in a thought experiment: on Sunday night, she falls asleep, her future experiences covered in uncertainty. A coin, unbiased in its chance, is tossed. If it lands heads, Monday will see her briefly wake up before she’s put back to sleep, with no memory when she wakes again.
If it lands tails, both Monday and Tuesday will follow this pattern, each waking indistinguishable from the previous. Each time she wakes, her understanding of both the day and the coin’s outcome remains unclear. Yet, she is asked a critical question: “What do you believe is the probability that the coin landed heads?”
This mental challenge splits theorists into two groups: the “Halfers” and the “Thirders.” Based on the coin’s natural fairness, the Halfer group firmly believes that the probability stays fixed at 1/2.
